Been stewing on this for a few days (might be controversial, but I don't really care)
I think my issue with takes that unironically excuse or downplay the impact of c!Quackity torturing c!Dream has nothing to do with misinterpreting authorial intent; we have no way to be absolutely sure what's going through the writer's head, and even if we did, everybody sees fiction differently.
Nor does it have anything to do with the morality of enjoying a fictional person's suffering. Because once again, that's all very subjective, the people suffering aren't real, and to be fair, sometimes it can be cathartic to watch a villain get everything they've done thrown back tenfold.
It's just that reading c!Quackity's story like that is... boring.
Like, even if you don't give two shits about c!Dream's feelings - and you shouldn't have to - there's so much other interesting stuff to work with!
I want to dig deep into how trauma affects the way a person processes their life and how they judge who is worthy of their trust. How people determine when others have crossed a moral line, how someone can continue to justify themselves even after they cross those very same lines, and what happens when they realize they've become the bad guy and still don't stop.
I want to watch how someone can be desensitized to constant violence, and the way it leaves marks that you can't scrub out. How you can ward off your own trembling at the memories of dead eyes and destroyed homes with slightly different examples of the same. How your gut sinks when you discover that the vicious thing inside you that you thought was given a safe, healthy, cathartic outlet is leaking into the world of the innocent.
I want to understand how you can carry a knife in one hand and wedding rings dangling on a chain from the other, held as far apart as you can reach, because you can't bear to cross those lines and stain something that was supposed to safe and peaceful and good. How you can look the child you're trying to avenge in the eyes and lie to him because you've felt his pain, but you also know he's kinder and better than you, and it's already enough that one person looks at you with fear, and you can't bear to see that fear mix with disappointment. How you can lie awake thinking about blank lines of paperwork and the grime beneath your nails and sly smiles and lost bets and broken promises (and screams and sobs that stopped being soothing a long time ago), and wonder what happens when the same sharp edge is turned against you and the ones you love, too.
I want to see how you can choose to put the blade down, change your plans, and trick your fuming heart into believing that it's not weakness or guilt holding you back. That it's all going to be worth it. That both of you are going to get what you deserve (and you already know what that is, that you're heading to the same place in hell as everyone you despise, that there's no turning back anymore, that you are irreparably soiled by what you've done here, and that your only hope is to leave a message behind and hope that someone, anyone, will remember you fondly-)
I want to question what it really means to "deserve" something, and wonder how much it really matters. I want to see the good, the bad, and everything in between. I want to see somebody go to the darkest depths imaginable, and still choose to return.
The prison arc and by extension the rest of the Las Nevadas arc is the perfect place to explore all of that. So why not?
12 notes
·
View notes
oh m ygod lets fUCKING GO another leftist cquackity enjoyer :sob: im so tired of telling people that minecraft politics =/= real life politics. I can support the torture of c!dream and him being in prison and also be a prison abolitionist you dumb fucks (not at you)
Ethically and narratively, c!Dream's torture is a frightening abuse of power that symbolizes the psychological and moral decline of its perpetrator, enabler, and victim alike. Despite the target having committed his own crimes and deserving to be held accountable in some fashion, an act as extreme, traumatic, and demonstrably ineffective as torture not only failed to extract a valuable life-saving asset or ensure the long-term welfare of the vulnerable, but desensitized all those involved to gratuitous violence and increased the likelihood of more bloodshed to come. c!Quackity was clearly spiralling to his darkest point over the course of the Las Nevadas arc, his reckless and vindictive actions will inevitably be reflected back on himself and those he loves, and were this situation to take place in our own world, I would fully and firmly oppose them.
...But come on, y'all. Look at his little suspenders and his little lopsided smile and his little speeches about moving forward from loss and his little gifts he gives to help his friends and his little wedding pavillion decorated with flowers and fountains and lanterns that the ones he cherished most never got to see. Don't you see how sad he is? Don't you want him to be happy? Doesn't he deserve to heal and grow and live in peace? Doesn't he deserve to go just a little bit apeshit now and then, as a treat? Those red splotches on his shirt just symbolize how full of love and passion he is, I promise, guys please-
12 notes
·
View notes