Visit Blog

Explore Tumblr blogs with no restrictions, modern design and the best experience.

Fun Fact

Tumblr paired up with Humans of New York to raise money for Hurricane Sandy relief.

Trending Blogs
#for once

Okay kinda, look i wrote a mini thesis when i found out TLOU2 deadass won GOTY, which is absolutely hilarious cause it’s beyond even my expectation, I didn’t expect them to give it the full RDR2 treatment, btw I picked a very good year to wizen up to the fact TGA is basically a circlejerk and the popular vote has no influience on the outcome [[So apparently its Golden Joystick which actually is people voted. “Gamers” really are just the definition of “Fuck you, Got Mine” and I hope everyone who voted for Naughty Dog under any circumstance has to work retail crunch until they learn empathy.]] BUT ANYWAYS I genuinely wrote the following out of interest, not anger. In fact I cant wait for all the people to explode because they still dont realize the game awards are a sham. 
this is ALL off the cuff, be warned, cause I basically rambled to friend about having stumbled onto a thesis prompt, I cut out the first half of it for that reason so here goes:

So then.

this entire thing?

It proves that “critics” don’t actually want video games to be video games. They don’t want video games to be art either. They just want video games to be movies

Writing is not a universal constant, because every medium tells stories in different ways

Do you judge the writing of a book the way you judge the writing of a movie? Does the fact a book wont have voice actors or background music make it movies but worse? of course not

so why do people keep acting like that’s how it works for video games?

A video game will never, NEVER be able to be as well written as a high tier film, not in terms of pure standalone writing. The same way a movie will never be as well written as a book in terms of pure standalone writing.

Undertale is probably the best written game ever made. the writing isn’t remotely as good as a B grade movie

because in a movie writing and acting are how you tell the story. That’s its strength

Video games have a different. fucking. strength: GAMEPLAY

When you think of “art” in video games, what comes to mind?

Maybe Shadow of the Colossus? Undertale? Braid? Journey? These all work.

And ya know what they have in common?

They are not “cinematic” and they are not “masterpieces of writing and acting”

in fact of those 4 games, 3 don’t actually have dialogue unless you seriously count those messages from Dormin

You know what they all have in common though?

They don’t use writing to convey their story, messages, themes, etc. They use gameplay

Movies treat videogame qualities to be detrimental in a film. people attribute this to contempt. It isn’t those people who say a movie being like a video game is bad? they are absolutely right.

And in that Exact. Same. Vein. VIdeo games shouldn’t be actively trying to be like movies

not if they want to be anything more than a B movie

Let’s just start with several examples of different ways video games create “artistic” narrative and experiences:

Shadow of the Colossus tells its story by having you realize that your actions as the player have unleashed a terrible evil. Braid sets its time travel gameplay mechanic in reverse at the end for its big story reveal. Journey has zero dialogue and through the way you traverse environments alone tells a grand epic. Undertale applies the idea of metanarrative to video games in a way unlike any other, something plenty of movies have done but no movie has ever been able to do to an even remote degree that Undertale did, because unlike a film the audience has direct input. Does that make metanarrative films like Fight Club, Inception, or far more historically famous than, either, a “Citizen Kane” type film if you’re gonna bring that stupid notion out, Sunset Boulevard, does that make it bad metanarrative? NO. IT MEANS ITS A DIFFERENT VERSION OF THAT STYLE.

Bastion is dialogue heavy, with constant narration, so is stanley parable, but both games have that narration dictated by the player’s action. In a movie narration can only dictate predetermined action, even if that means unreliable narration or outright lying in the narration, that won’t change the fact what it describes is predetermined because it’s a movie. In a game, it could be different every single time.

There are far more examples of artistic games that are art specifically because they arent trying to be art in the same sense as a movie

Papers Please for example

THAT could genuinely be equivalent to Schindler’s List

Because you are deciding who lives and dies, you TECHNICALLY aren’t, but you know what happens to the people you deny. You know exactly what will happen to them.(edited)

so do you let them in even if it’s not legal, deducting your own pay and making it that much more likely you can’t afford food or heat that night for your family? or do you send them knowingly to the gulag?

In a film that already is a powerful message and like I said it genuinely isnt that far off from schindler’s list. As a movie done right, papers please could be a harrowing story about those kinds of things. But it wouldn’t be any better, nor would it likely be told in a way remotely similar to how you experience games.

because again: they. are. different. mediums.

That’s what it means to have different mediums, you can tell the same story in completely different ways to elicit different, equally meaningful responses

In schindler’s list what makes it harrowing is that its a man who was on his way to wealth who is sacrificing that wealth and his own safety to save the lives of innocents being persecuted

the emotional response is from seeing how Oskar Schindler deals with the situation he’s ended up in and whether he has the resolve to save those people or if he would sell them out to secure his own prospects

In Paper’s Please it’s not even close to the same

You have no idea how grand scale the things going on are, you only have bits of info to piece together with the only context given being you are a border patrol guard who will serve your authoritarian "country”

There’s a game called Not Tonight that has the same gameplay but gets these details wrong

it makes the resistance obviously the good guys, there’s little to no penalty to helping them over the state.

in that aspect its MORE like Schindler’s list because obviously the nazis are the bad guys

so why isn’t the comparison Not Tonight and Schindler’s List?

because the idea of a straightforward story where you know sheltering them is good and its bad to sell them out is part of film storytelling, where you are an onlooker

In Papers Please the way you’re torn between what to do and who is worth saving and who isn’t, whether you should back resistance or serve the state? That struggle you as the player feel is the struggle Schindler’s List puts on screen for you to OBSERVE, not to be a part of.

Not Tonight in terms of its story and writing is more similar to Schindler’s list. And that’s why it’s explicitly less artistic than Paper’s Please. *Because if you make a game more similar to a movie, you lose the strengths of the medium of games without actually gaining the strengths of the medium of film.*

2 notes · See All
ripousText

Totally adding some sailor moon ladies. Just need to watch the show first.

3 notes · See All

I want to be in the woods with a bunch of dogs in a cabin. Fire going with wine and food and some close friends and soft music playing. I want snow falling outside and I want a feeling of being acknowledged and safe.

1 notes · See All

So you know how when klance didn’t happen, the voltron fandom created the leakria ship and pretty much destroyed the canon side of voltron?

What if we did that with miraculous ladybug? Cause I feel like we could do that?

I mean we’re pretty much already doing that with maribat but if a team of people wanted to reinvent miraculous via discord, I would definitely be down for that.

50 notes · See All

so it just occurred to me that one of the reasons why the host of the Noldor following Fingolfin were, on the whole, ready to forgive Maedhros was that they were already deeply invested in the idea that suffering brings absolution.

The people that struggled across the Helcaraxe see themselves as wronged: the Kinslaying at Alqualonde is not their sin, their hands are (mostly) clean, they are righteous in their anger, they were betrayed.  (Let us not ask about how many of them would have sailed on the stolen ships.)  They have paid in blood and toil, their suffering shrives them (it does not; Finrod learns this).

Maedhros stood aside at Losgar, he suffered mightily at the hands of Morgoth, his suffering shrives him (it does not; Maedhros, and all Middleearth, learn this).

The thing is, I think: this suffering does buy something.   But it is only partial coin, and the fatal mistake of the Noldor in Middleearth is to mistake the partial coin for the whole.

130 notes · See All
Next Page