Cherry Bomb | Billy Hargrove x Reader || PART TWO
PART ONE
The official Cherry Bomb Playlist (tm)
Masterlist
Is this beta read? No. Did I finish this at 1 am? Yes. Is it good? I sure hope so! 12,800+ words of Cherry Bomb goodness, for your reading pleasure!
Warnings: f slur/homophobia, verbal abuse, vague nsfw stuff
Tags: @smenny @infinitelyforgotten @littlewinter1917 @djiafjaidjcj @pans-fav-shank @notwithawhimper @buckysjuicyplums @local-yn @northwmar @ttomholland2008 @secretly-a-weeb @jaynorama @all-bi-myselfs-blog @eddiemunsonswife21 @kingexplosionm @jaziscool @killer-queen101 @hannahnikohl @piper570 @slut4fictionalcharacters @pawneeismyhome @eirugybrkhs @a-rockstars-bitch @queenofstarsanddarkness @smelly-sock @frogtits1 @itwasagathaallalonggg @kat-ara6 @ifyouwerethemoon @aangsupremacy @bilesxbilinskixlahey @itsnanabun @makepastanotwar13 @brooklynmarie @multi-fandom205 @lanalanaban @fanatics30
“Hey, Hargrove.”
“Hey there, Doll.” Billy greeted you as you stepped out of your car. He looked just as gorgeous as ever, brilliant blue eyes trained on you and following your every movement. “It’s icy. Careful.”
“I think I know a little more about icy winters than you, California Boy,” you snorted a laugh as you shut the car door and faced him.
The morning air was chilly, your breath coming out in little puffs. You were used to it, the sometimes frigid Indiana weather, but you could tell that Billy didn’t like it one bit. Not that he liked anything about Hawkins anyways.
“Whatever,” he sneered, amazing you, as always, with his ability to have so much attitude so early in the morning. You wondered how hard he had to try at it, or if he even had to try at all.
He was wearing his jean jacket, smoking a cigarette, and looking like someone shoved a particularly rough stick up his ass. Everyone in the parking lot was watching him, the girls still hoping they had a chance—because, after all, wasn’t Billy Hargrove a total player? How could he not be?—while the guys called to him with the hopes that they could get his attention and then get on his good side. He was focused on you, though, looking down at you with an expression you had come to discover was his version of warm. He was still way too cool to do or say anything mushy, of course, and neither of you had clarified where exactly you stood, but you were something, and everybody seemed to know it.
After all, they watched the way Billy carried things for you, how he opened doors, how he always seemed to want you up against his side. Tommy H had already started a rumor that you were a total slut and you were totally good at it, because how else could you have Billy Hargrove eating out of the palm of your hand like that? You were obviously actually very experienced, and you probably did it in the back of your car, and the Camaro, every day after class. Obviously.
You didn’t really care about the rumors, not even the nastier ones that Carol was spreading out of jealousy. You were happy with Billy around. You knew a side of him that he’d never allow anyone else to see, and after the night he had climbed through your window, something had changed between you. There was some sort of a silent understanding developing, an agreement that you wouldn’t bring it up and he would maybe not be an ass. And he wasn’t, at least not to you—he was polite, or at least his version of polite, and that was fine. He was sweet when he wanted to be, and now, you were starting to see why he was always so ready to fight and rage at anyone who looked at him funny.
You never brought it up, though. You held his face so gently whenever the two of you were alone, and you stroked his cheeks with your thumbs in a way that he totally thought made him look like a pussy but he appreciated nonetheless, and you spoke softly and just sat with him when he needed the peace. Billy didn’t explain anything about why his father was so rough on him, and even though you wanted to know why Neil Hargrove was like that, you didn’t ask. You didn’t press. Because you figured maybe Billy needed a refuge from it, and maybe he would talk about it when he was ready.
When he trusted you enough.
Because Billy did trust you, but he didn’t know how to tell you what it was like living with his father. He didn’t know how to go about explaining how much he missed his mother and wished she hadn’t walked out on him, or how fucked up in the head he was from all of it. He was too afraid of hearing himself say anything out loud.
So he didn’t. Not yet.
He just followed you around like a lovesick puppy instead, because that’s what he was, and that was the only thing he could do.
“Everyone is staring,” you said in a hushed voice as Billy grabbed you by the hips and pulled you up against him.
“So let ‘em stare.”
“Billy…”
“What, doll?”
There it was. The pet name that always made you melt a little.
“Let’s just go inside,” you grumbled, picking at the front of his jacket in an attempt to ignore the heat of everyone’s glares.
“What, you suddenly shy now?” He sneered. Because, as you had come to learn, Billy Hargrove didn’t know how to tease. He only knew how to taunt.
But still, it was his way of being playful, and you were slowly learning how to speak his language.
“No,” you snapped. “I just prefer having you all to myself…”
Your tone made him grin as he leaned down to catch your lips in a kiss. “There she is.”
“Who?” You asked when he pulled away.
He smirked. “My girl.”
You felt your heart flutter a little bit, a blush spreading across your cheeks. “Yeah, yeah...”
“Thought you were all tough and didn’t care about the staring,” he commented as he threw his arm around your shoulders.
“I just hate the way Carol’s always undressing you with her eyes.” You said matter-of-factly, glaring at the group of girls standing with Tommy H and a few other guys from the basketball team.
Carol and Tina scoffed when you made eye contact, immediately turning away to pretend they hadn’t been watching and imagining themselves exactly where you were. You weren’t looking forward to the next time they caught you in the locker room alone, but at least if one of them swung first, you’d have a good excuse to finish the fight.
Billy looked over at Carol and wrinkled his nose. Yeah, if he didn’t have you around, she’d probably be an easy fuck. Never mind that she was dating Tommy, the guy who loved gassing Billy up and always acted like he wanted to be his friend. Carol would probably jump at the chance to be alone with him, and then sleep with him as her own way of getting back at her parents or her boyfriend or whoever else was pissing her off. Because that’s what Billy was used to—getting physical attention from girls who liked him for his looks and his dick and the fact that he was the wildest thing in a town like Hawkins.
Besides you, it turned out.
And he hadn’t even gotten in your pants yet.
As you walked inside, he glanced down at you. You were always more tired in the morning, always a little sluggish. He thought it was cute. He thought just about everything about you was cute, and it drove him a little crazy knowing that he hadn’t even made a serious move on you yet, and you hadn’t tried to fuck him in the back of the car. He knew you wanted him. He knew you liked having him around, and he knew you liked making out with him. So why weren’t you trying to ride his dick, too? It’s what girls always wanted from him. Some guys, too…even though he’d never hear the end of it from Neil if he got caught with another guy.
But that was an entirely different issue, and he was more interested in you.
Were you scared? …were you a virgin? The thought brought a smirk to his lips. If you were, he wanted to be your first. And your last. And your only. Although you’d probably look real cute with another guy’s dick in your mouth, but as long as Billy was still involved, it didn’t count—
“Earth to Billy? …hello?” You saved your hand in front of his face and he realized that the two of you had reached your locker. “Were you even listening to me?”
“Sorry, babe,” he said smoothly as he leaned up against the lockers next to yours. “Got distracted.”
“By what?” You growled.
“Thinkin’ about how good you’d look on your hands and knees for me.”
You stared at him. You willed your face not to flush, and you just kept your mouth shut as you stared at him.
“Shut up,” you mumbled as you opened your locker, trying to ignore the butterflies in your stomach.
“What? You’re so bashful today, doll.” He leered at you.
You rolled your eyes as you pulled a textbook out. “It is eight in the morning, Billy.”
“So?” He grinned. “Why don’t you wanna talk about it?”
“Because I don’t feel like it.” You said, avoiding his handsome face as your own began heating up.
He gasped dramatically. “Princess, are you…a virgin?”
His mocking tone was starting to piss you off, and you suddenly slammed your locker shut before glaring at him. “Fuck off, Hargrove.”
“Oh, that’s it, isn’t it?”
Your nostrils flared angrily as you turned on your heel. “I’m not talking to you!”
“See you at lunch, sweetheart!” He called after you, watching you go with a wolfish grin on his face. Oh, you were a total virgin.
It was cute.
———————
You didn’t feel like explaining to Billy that you were not, in fact, a virgin, but you sat and simmered about it all morning rather than just ignoring your conversation. He was so fucking annoying when he wanted to be, an absolute menace. You had grown used to him, the way he talked and behaved, but even you had your limit.
And besides, why should you want to tell him all about your awkward sexual escapades? None of them mattered. You’d been stupid sophomore year and hooked up with a guy who had no idea what he was doing, and it had left you feeling weird and in pain while he got to go brag to all of his friends. Then, the same thing happened junior year…only that time, the guy had decided to tell the entire world, and in return, you had beaten the shit out of him. So far, your only pleasurable experiences had been a few drunk nights with Robin…and you could only imagine how long Billy would go on and on about that if you told him.
So no, it wasn’t that you were a virgin. It was just that sometimes, when you thought about it for too long, you wished that you still were. It was kind of corny, but you wished your first time had been with someone you actually liked, rather than some dude you never really spoke to again.
Someone like Billy.
You tried to stay focused and not think about it too much. By the time lunch rolled around, though, it was hard not to let your thoughts wander…especially with Billy smirking across the table at you.
And you already knew exactly what was on his mind.
“You know, my brothers would probably kill you just for thinking like that.” You said haughtily, digging a sandwich out of your bag and throwing it at him.
He caught it easily, grinning that stupid grin at you. “Better not let ‘em find out then, huh?”
“You’re insufferable.”
“I seem to recall you kissing me first, doll,” he drawled as he unwrapped his food. “You remember. Down at Lover’s Lake? When you practically jumped me and sucked my face off?”
You rolled your eyes. “We seem to remember things a little differently.”
“Oh? Then why don’t you enlighten me? And don’t leave out any of the juicy details, I wanna hear everything.”
You fixed him with a glare. He had laid a trap, and you had waltzed right on into it. You couldn’t be too mad at him, though, not when his eyes were sparkling like that and the side of his mouth was pulled up in a lopsided grin.
“Actually….” You returned the look, biting your lip. “…I think I might need a reminder.”
“Oh, baby, you sure do speak my language…”
He leaned towards you and you stopped him with a hand in his face. “Take me out for food tonight and then maybe we’ll talk.”
Rather than deflate, Billy actually seemed to make himself look larger, taking your demands as a challenge more than defeat. If nothing else, he was tenacious.
“Deal, babe.” He said before sinking his teeth into the sandwich your mother had so lovingly prepared for him that morning. “I’ll pick you up. Six o’ clock.”
“Fine.” You said. “Six it is.”
And just like he said, Billy Hargrove showed up on your doorstep at six, wearing his leather jacket and a silky red button down that exposed a fair portion of his chest. He had spent the better part of an hour getting ready for you, and yes, he had patted cologne on all the spots that mattered, because he was, of course, hoping that he might get lucky tonight.
He was leaning with his elbow on the frame when he saw the knob twist and the door swing open, but he was greeted by the sight of not you, but one of your brothers instead.
Curtis.
The one who liked him the least.
“Well, well, look what the cat dragged in,” he sneered.
Billy met him with a sharp glare. Curt was definitely the meanest of your brothers, and even though the two of them had managed to share a few laughs in the time since Billy had met your family, Curt still wasn’t a fan of the town bad boy dicking around with his baby sister. Billy couldn’t really blame him; he didn’t even get along with his sister, and he still wanted to chase off any snot nosed kid who looked at her for too long.
“Curtis, who are you glowering at now?” a woman asked.
Her voice had Billy’s glare immediately softening. He loved your mother. He really, really did. He was too afraid to admit how much he liked your family—even with Curt and his constant shitty attitude towards him—but he actually felt at home there, in your little old house next to the auto shop, and a lot of it was due to the way your mother treated him.
“Hello, ma’am,” Billy greeted in his friendliest voice as Curt reluctantly moved out of his way.
“Hello, Billy,” you mom smiled. She was watching from the front hall, seemingly on her way towards the living room, leaning on her forearm crutches as she paused to say hi.
Billy didn’t know exactly why she used them. He had never asked, because even though he could be a total asshole, getting too nosey with the best maternal figure in his life wasn’t something he wanted to do. All he knew came from the few snippets you had told him, things like how she had to stop driving for some reason and how she hated the pitying looks she got at the grocery store. Billy couldn’t really imagine anyone pitying your mother, because it seemed very clear to him that she was very much in charge of your family and so far all of her kids had turned out perfectly fine, but he, much like you and your brothers, would sock a stranger in the jaw if they ever disrespected her.
So, yeah. Billy was a big fan of your mom.
“She’s still upstairs,” she said with a warm smile. “I’m sure Curt would love to make himself useful and go get her. Wouldn’t you, Curt? And no yelling, please. You know Danny is trying to sleep.”
He huffed and gave Billy another glare before jogging up the stairs, finally giving Billy some breathing room. He didn’t hate Curt. He really didn’t. But god, he wanted to get in a fist fight just so they could settle their shit.
“C’mon, hon.” Your mother said, making her way through the doorway to the living room. “She’ll be a minute. She was helping the boys in the shop this afternoon and got a little behind.”
Billy should’ve known that you���d be the one running late.
He followed your mom, sitting down on the couch you had once let him sleep on after a party. She settled into her armchair, reaching for a mug on the side table and taking a sip before smiling appreciatively.
“Hot cocoa,” she said, nodding towards a matching mug on the coffee table. “Made you some, too.”
And, as always, Billy was taken aback by your family’s kindness towards him.
“Thank you, ma’am, but you didn’t have to—“
“Don’t give me that, Billy,” she growled. “You’re a guest in our home. Besides, haven’t you seen my boys? When I make hot cocoa, I have to make gallons of the stuff so they all get enough. There’s plenty to go around.”
That was a theme he had noticed in your house. The table was always covered in food, there was always extra juice at breakfast, and you never seemed to run out of snacks. It wasn’t like his family was totally broke, but the way Neil ran things, he and Susan always seemed more concerned with acting put together rather than actually enjoying things like family dinner time or an extra helping of dessert. In fact, Billy had been on the receiving end of angry words more than once for going for that extra helping.
At your house, though, eating to your heart’s content was encouraged, and the food was always so good that there shouldn’t have ever been leftovers, except somehow there always were, and your mom always insisted that Billy take some home with him.
He picked up the warm mug and the hot cocoa was absolutely delicious. Your mother must have been able to see it in his face as he tasted it, because she chuckled and leaned back in her chair slightly before giving him some lighthearted teasing.
“I thought the California boy might need some hot cocoa to get through our midwestern winters,” she laughed.
“It’s wonderful, ma’am.” He said. “Thank you.”
“There’s no need to thank me,” she smiled. “But I appreciate it nonetheless.”
“Curtis! Get out of my fucking way!” You yelled upstairs.
“No yelling, shrimpy!” Curtis yelled back.
“Will you two shut up? I’m trying to fucking sleep in here!” Danny snarled from his room.
Billy immediately tensed. To him, shouting inside the house meant fighting, and fighting meant that he was about to be shoved up against the wall by two big fists as they grabbed handfuls of his nice shirt. To him, it meant that he had done something wrong, something that he deserved to be punished for even though he didn’t really get what it was. To him, while it was normal, it was a big deal, an event that would have his ribs aching for a while afterwards.
But in your house, it was nothing more than a few siblings, all born fairly close together, who bickered and fought just like any other family. It was just your most annoying brother doing what he did best, and you yelling about it because you were the youngest and the smallest which often meant you had to be the loudest. That was all. You fought with your brothers all the time, but they never hurt you—never on purpose, at least—and they never even said anything very bad.
It made Billy a little jealous.
Your mom saw the way he was suddenly so alert and she sighed. “Never a moment’s peace around here.”
Billy cleared his throat and nodded, trying to cover it all up with his usual attitude. “Seems like.”
“How’s your sister?” She asked, prodding slightly.
“Max?” Billy thought for a moment, looking down at his mug. “…she’s fine, I guess.”
“She’s lucky to have you, you know.”
His eyes snapped up to meet hers. “What?”
“You’re a good boy, Billy.” She reached over, patting his hand. “Max is lucky to have you there to protect her.”
He didn’t know what to say, so he simply stared. Max hated him. And he didn’t like Max very much. He kept an eye on her, sure, because he had to, and because they had been forced to come to terms with their new blended family and forced to admit that neither of them could control their circumstances. Billy had a bad attitude, yeah. So did Max sometimes. And he wanted to keep her safe, he really did, because even though he didn’t like her and she was annoying and always in his way, they were pretty much stuck with each other.
He wished he could be there for her the way your brothers were for you. Even though that meant that they didn’t trust him as far as they could throw him—which, actually, for Kenny might be pretty far—Billy figured that they were right not to. He wouldn’t trust a guy like him around his sister, and he really couldn’t blame these guys for the way they acted sometimes.
Except Curt.
Curt was just an asshole.
Luckily for Billy, you came rushing down the stairs just in time for him to avoid furthering the conversation, and when you appeared in the doorway, he immediately jumped to his feet. You looked perfect, wearing a dress that was a little more than casual but by no means formal, and even after all your scrubbing and fussing, there was still some grease on your arms.
Billy loved that, because it was so you.
“Hey,” you said, smiling at him. “You ready?”
“Are you?” He scoffed, forgetting that your mother was right there for a moment.
You scowled are him. “Yes. I am. And I’m starving, so let’s go.”
He said a hasty goodbye to your mother and she chuckled, watching as you seized Billy’s hand and practically dragged him out the front door. You could see the Camaro sitting there in the driveway next to your Barracuda, its midnight blue exterior appearing almost black as dusk fell.
“Where we goin’, Princess?” Billy asked as he walked around to the passenger side, opening the door for you.
“That little diner in town,” you said as you slipped in. “I’m seriously in the mood for a shake and a greasy burger.”
He shoved the door shut once you were comfortably situated, walking around to the driver’s side and climbing in. As he jammed the key in the ignition and turned it, he lunged for you, finding that you were already waiting with your chin tilted up and your hand reaching for his.
Billy’s kisses were always hungry. Starving, practically, as if his lips crashing against yours was the only thing that could keep him alive. His hand found your thigh and gave it a warm squeeze before drifting to entangle his fingers with yours, brushing the pad of his thumb over your knuckles. It was one of his gentler habits, something small and soft amidst the flames of the wildfire that was Billy Hargrove, and it was something that reminded you that despite all of his rage and bad attitude, he was still just a confused boy who had put up as many walls as possible to keep himself safe.
“I missed you.” He admitted as he pulled away, hand on the gearshift as he backed out of the driveway.
“You saw me just a few hours ago.”
“Doesn’t mean I didn’t miss you.”
You couldn’t help but smile at that one. “You know, you’re kinda sweet, when you wanna be.”
“I’m always sweet.” he grunted as he turned into the road and floored it.
You snorted in amusement. “Sure.”
He gave you a sidelong glance. “Y’know, about this morning...”
You sighed and looked out the window. “You mean when you were being an annoying asshole?”
He scrunched his nose angrily, eyes dark and narrow. “I was not an asshole.”
“Well, you were sure as hell being annoying.” you huffed.
He wanted to yell, or at least stomp away before he got the chance to. But he was trapped in the car with you, and he didn’t really want to shout or swear or blow up, even though that was his first instinct.
“Sweetheart...”
“I’m not a virgin.” you mumbled, cutting him off. “So you can kiss that fantasy of yours goodbye.”
He glanced at you again. Your head was resting on the window, eyes focused on nothing in particular. Billy suddenly felt bad, because he felt like it was his fault that you were so put out now, and he really fucking wished that he could just...be better.
“That doesn’t matter to me.” he said, assuming that you were angry with him because you thought that’s all he cared about.
“But the thing is...I sort of wish I was, because I would way rather my first time be with you.”
His nostrils flared as fresh anger coursed through him. “Who was it?”
“You don’t need to beat anybody up, Billy.”
“I want to.”
“It’s fine.” you sighed, finally looking at him. “Nothing that bad happened. It just...wasn’t great. And I just figure it would be...better...with you.”
He watched you carefully out of the corner of his eye for a moment.
Better.
Yeah.
It would be.
Billy wanted to worship you. He wanted to show you how much you meant to him. He wanted to take as much time as he could with you so that he could do things properly, and when he got the chance--if he got the chance--he fully intended to make you forget all about your past experiences.
“Look, babe.” he cleared his throat. “I won’t lie. I wanted to be your first...but only because I’d do it right.”
You felt heat creeping up your neck and face. “I know you would.”
“Damn straight.” he growled.
“And don’t, uh...don’t beat anybody up. Okay?”
“Why not?” he asked angrily. “If some guy hurt you then I’m gonna--”
“Because I already did.” you huffed, crossing your arms over your chest. “And he didn’t really hurt me, he just went and told literally everybody about it. It just...sucked.”
You could see that Billy was still angry, his grip on the steering wheel tightening until his knuckles were white. “Point him out if you see him.”
“Billy...”
“What?”
“I appreciate it. Really.” you put a hand on his arm. “But it’s not important.”
“It is.”
“Billy.”
“What?”
“It’s been years. And I would rather not think about it.” you gave his bicep a squeeze, your fingers lingering on the sleeve of his leather jacket.
He glanced down at you and you could see a fondness in his eyes, something he never offered anybody else. “I just wanna see you happy, baby.”
You felt your heart skip a beat at his admission. He’d said things along those lines before, but this was the most straightforward he had ever been...or maybe you were just really learning how to speak his language, and if he had said that to anyone else, it wouldn’t have had the same impact. But for you, that was practically a declaration of love, and you could feel it settling in your chest like a warm ball of butterflies.
“I am happy, Billy.”
His lips spread into a lopsided grin--not a smirk, a real grin--and by the look in his eyes, you could guess that if he wasn’t driving a car entirely too quickly down a residential street, his lips would be on yours.
“Good. Now lemme buy you dinner.”
You mirrored his grin. “Yes please. I’m fucking starving.”
-----------
Whenever the two of you went out, which really wasn’t all that often, you received stares. Billy, the bad boy all the way from California, and you, the mechanic’s aggressive daughter, painted a picture that had had Hawkins’ more uptight residents clutching their pearls. It didn’t bother you any more than Carol did, though, and if it got to Billy, he never showed it.
“You got a curfew, Princess?” He asked as he watched you sink your teeth into a cheeseburger.
You shook your head, then paused to swallow. “…I mean, it’s sorta ten, but you know it’s not a big deal. Why? Do you?”
He leaned back, one arm draped over the back of his seat. “Nah. Neil and Susan are gonna be out late.”
At the mention of his father and stepmom, you frowned. “Aren’t they gonna be pissed that you’re out, too?”
“It’s a free country.”
“But shouldn’t you be watching Max?”
Billy rolled his eyes and grabbed his chocolate milkshake. “She’s out with her shitty little friends. She’s fine.”
“Won’t they be mad that—“
“They’re not gonna know,” he said. “How are they gonna know? Are you gonna tell them?”
“What? Shut up.” You scoffed. “I just don’t want you to get in trouble.”
“Thanks for the concern, but it’s fine.”
You could tell that it wasn’t, but you dropped it anyway. “How’s your shake?”
“It’s alright.”
“Only alright?”
“Fine. It’s good.”
You grinned. “It’s okay to admit that you like things like shakes, you know. It’s not like it’s embarrassing. Everybody likes them.”
Billy made an annoyed sound and you laughed before taking another bite. You could tell that he was enjoying it. In fact, you could tell that he had quite a sweet tooth, specifically for chocolate, and you thought that it was…well, sweet.
Billy knew he had a thing for chocolate. It was his favorite flavor of soft serve, shakes, and cake. But…his dad loved to crack shitty jokes and make wise comments at Billy’s expense, and it left him a little ashamed. Maybe, if that’s all Neil ever did, Billy would care less, but coupled with everything else he liked to throw at him, it just made Billy want to hide it all.
Not from you, though. He liked sharing chocolate shakes with you, and he didn’t like hiding things, even though he barely knew how to open up.
“How is she?” you asked, trying to get him to keep talking.
“Who?” he grunted.
“Max.”
“Why does everyone care so much?” he growled, shooting you a glare.
You glared back at him, ever stubborn. “It’s just a question, Billy.”
“You’ve never even actually met her.” he grumbled, returning to his shake as if it would save him.
“No, but I mean...I could,” you suggested.
His glare only hardened. “She’s an annoying little sister with a bad attitude who makes my life harder. That’s all there is to it. She’s got annoying friends and annoying hobbies and--”
“Billy.”
“What?”
“You know that I know what it’s like to have annoying siblings,” you laughed. “I mean, Curt tried to throw me down the stairs this morning.”
“So?”
“So I bet Max isn’t all that bad,” you shrugged. “And I bet she doesn’t hate you as much as you always say she does.”
“Then why’s she always being a little shit and getting me in trouble?” He snapped, folding his arms over his chest and leaning back against the back of the booth.
You frowned. “Because she’s a little sister, and she probably doesn’t realize what she’s doing. I’m sure she cares about you—“
Billy scoffed. “If she cared, then she’d stop finding new ways to get him pissed off at me.”
You closed your mouth and let his words simmer. You didn’t need to ask to know that he was talking about his dad, and you weren’t about to pretend that you were an expert on Billy’s family. In fact, he kept you as in the dark about it as possible, avoiding the subject whenever it came up, and you couldn’t really blame him. Nothing that you knew about Neil made him sound like a good guy, much less a good father…but Max was just a kid having a hard time, not totally unlike Billy.
You decided to change the subject. “Soooo…Valentine’s Day is coming up.”
“What about it?” Billy asked, even though he was very aware.
“Well, I was wondering if you wanted to do anything.”
“Isn’t the guy supposed to be asking the girl out?” He asked.
“Well the guy is taking too long,” you growled. 
That managed to pull a chuckle out of him and he sat up again, elbows on the table as he leaned towards you. “Maybe the girl is just bein’ too impatient.”
It was your turn to roll your eyes, something that Billy Hargrove made you do a lot. “I don’t think I am. I’ve never really had a Valentine, though, so I guess I don’t—“
“You haven’t?” He asked, actually looking surprised. “Sweetheart, you should have guys linin’ up to ask you out.”
“Nope. Just you.” You sighed. “Not that that’s a bad thing, though, you’re more than enough—“
“Less competition.” He grinned, grabbing his straw in between his teeth and finishing his milkshake. “You wanna get outta here, baby?”
“…you didn’t answer me—“
“Don’t worry about it, Princess.” He started to stand, pulling some cash out of his pocket and tossing it onto the table.
“…whatever you say, Billy.” You grabbed the rest of your burger, holding it in one hand to finish as you walked out while Billy slung an arm around your shoulders.
You knew the two of you looked like troublemakers, maybe even more than usual as Billy lit a cigarette and an old lady practically jumped away as you passed her. You really didn’t care, though; in a town like Hawkins, where everybody knew everybody, you couldn’t avoid the stares and the rumors.
So you didn’t bother trying to. You just got in the car, talking about normal, benign things while Billy drove out to the lake, and then you both climbed into the backseat and he kissed you so gently that you could tell he was holding himself back.
“It’s okay,” you murmured, fingers clinging to his red shirt as he hovered over you. “You can do more.”
“Baby…” he groaned against your collarbone, “I don’t wanna fuck up with you…”
“You won’t,” you smiled, tilting your head back against the seat. “I promise.”
You could feel his grip on your waist tighten and then the windows were steaming up and your dress was bunched up around your hips while Billy showed you that his mouth was good for way more than just talking. Your face was flushed as he looked up at you, your fingers tangled in his curly hair, and he knew that he could stay there for hours if you let him. Because you were the best thing that had ever come stomping into his life, and he was determined to show you that.
———————
Try as Billy might to discourage you from meeting his sister, Hawkins was too small a place not to bump into her eventually. It was only a few days later, in fact, when you spotted a red headed girl standing near the Camaro impatiently, and with Billy preoccupied with basketball practice, you knew this was your chance.
“Hey!” You called, jogging towards her. “You’re Max, right?”
“…yeah,” she said, looking you over warily. “Who the hell are you?”
“Oh, I’m—“
“Forget it, I know who you are.” She rolled her eyes. “You’re always with Billy.”
“…yeah, I guess I am.” You leaned against your car as you looked at her. Maybe Billy was right about her attitude. “Are you waiting for him?”
She sighed and held up her skateboard. “Yeah. Can’t exactly get very far when the roads are all gross and slushy like this.”
You smirked. “Yeah, the Midwest isn’t exactly great in the winter. But, uh…I can give you a ride, if you don’t feel like waiting. It’s kind of shitty out.”
Max stared at you for a moment, as if she couldn’t bring herself to trust someone that hung around her brother so much. But the weather really was shitty, and it looked like it was going to start sleeting or something, and she really didn’t want to deal with Billy.
“…okay. Fine.” She decided, looking at your car. “You don’t drive like him, do you?”
“With you in the car? No way.” You snorted, walking around to the driver’s side door. “With him? Maybe.”
Max cracked a smile and climbed in, and soon, the two of you were actually chatting and laughing, and you were finding that Max Mayfield really wasn’t that bad. Maybe it was because Billy wasn’t around, or maybe it was just because you were a girl, but Max was actually almost friendly, and you were starting to feel a little bit hopeful that you could have a good relationship with her even if Billy couldn’t.
“Turn here.” she said as you approached a street sign that read Cherry Ln.
You did as she instructed and turned slowly, the Barracuda rumbling as you crept up the street. The houses on Cherry Lane were small, and to some Hawkins families, it wasn’t a great place. Some of the residences tended to look a little rundown, a little in need of love, and compared to places like the Harrington house...well, actually, they couldn’t compare at all. Cherry Lane just wasn’t a spectacular place, and that was that.
“It’s up here. 4819.” Max said. “You can let me out here. I’ll walk.”
You glanced at her. “Why? I can pull into the driveway--”
“Because if my mom or Neil are home, they’ll see that Billy didn’t give me a ride.” she said, looking down. “And he was supposed to.”
“...oh. Right.” you cleared your throat as you hit the brakes as gently as you could. “Well, this is your stop, then.”
“Thanks.” she mumbled as she grabbed her bag and skateboard.
“No problem,” you said, watching as she climbed out and started up the road. You couldn’t see any cars in the driveway at 4819, but you weren’t about to take the chance. It hadn’t even occurred to you that you could be getting Billy into more trouble, and you hated the idea that you had the potential to cause him more pain at the hands of his dad.
As you drove home, you hoped that Billy would make it home before his parents did...and as luck would have it, he did, and until Max mentioned exactly who had given her a ride, he was seriously pissed off at her. The universe was on his side, though, because there was no sign of Susan or Neil.
There was no sign of Susan or Neil because, as it turned out, Susan was still at work, and Neil was busy arguing with a mechanic.
A mechanic you happened to know very well.
When you pulled up to your house and hopped out of the car, you could see that there was a customer in the shop. That was pretty normal. Someone coming to pick up their car--even yelling about it--was something that came with the territory of working on cars. You had come home from school only to chat with the Wheelers or the Harringtons or Byers plenty of times. This time, though, as you walked up to the garage, you didn’t recognize the customer’s voice. That also wasn’t super strange; while Hawkins was small, there were tons of people you didn’t interact with, and you weren’t exactly a social butterfly.
“What the hell do you mean you don’t have the goddamn parts?” a man asked, his voice raised to a level just below yelling.
As you slipped into the shop, you saw a middle aged man standing near the desk, your father and Kenny just on the other side of it. When you glanced around, you spotted Danny and Curt working on cars…but when you looked closer, you realized that they were paying way more attention to this customer than their work, and that was…weird.
The customer was kind of a big guy. Not bigger than your brothers or your dad, though, but his shoulders were broad and he held himself with a very square posture in an effort to seem larger than he was. It would have made you laugh if you weren’t so put off by him.
“They’re on the way.” Your father said as politely as he possibly could, his voice somewhat strained. “Should be in by the end of the week. We’ll give you a call.”
“You know damn well that’s not good enough,” the man growled. “I bring my car to you, I expect service, not waiting an entire extra week for parts that you should have on hand.”
“Unless you wanna go all the way to the factory and walk ‘em back yourself, I suggest you sit tight, Mr. Hargrove.” Kenny growled back.
Your eyes widened.
“I wasn’t talking to you, boy.”
Your eyes widened even more.
You heard the clatter of metal on concrete and glanced over to see that Curt had dropped a wrench. He and Danny were both straightening up, glaring daggers at Billy’s father, and you finally understood why they had been so interested in what should have been a boring conversation.
“Neil, your car is fine to be driven. Your parts will be in in a few days, and we’ll take care of everything then.” You dad said.
“Did you not hear what I goddamn said?” Neil snapped. “That’s not good enough—“
Despite the fact that this was Neil Hargrove, despite the fact that this was the guy who abused your best-friend-maybe-boyfriend, despite the fact that he was bigger than you and louder than you and scarier than you…you cleared your throat.
Everyone turned to look at you. Your dad looked exasperated. Your brothers looked concerned. And Neil looked pissed off.
“Mr. Hargrove,” you piped up, gripping the strap of your backpack tightly, “there’s nothing else you can do about it right now. Yelling won’t get anyone anywhere.”
You could see his face growing red, but instead of scaring you, it just made you angrier.
“Don’t interrupt when the men are talking,” he snapped.
You felt like you had just been slapped in the face. Maybe you were being foolish, or maybe you were simply blinded by your anger, but you wanted to punch him in the nose more than anything. Before you could, though, Danny was dragging you back out the door, and you were resisting with all your might.
“Hey! What’s your problem?” You asked angrily, digging your heels into the gravel as he pulled you towards the house.
“Would you chill out for a second?” He asked.
“How can you ask me to chill out when that’s—“
“Billy’s dad.” Danny stopped and sighed. “I know.”
“So you see why I can’t just—“
“Hey.” He gave you a serious look. “Stay out of it. For real. He’s a dick, but he’s still a customer. Dad ‘n Kenny’ll take care of it.”
As much as you wanted to argue, you were really starting to run out of the footing for it. “…yeah. Fine.”
“I’ll come get you when he’s gone. Deal?”
“Deal.” You grumbled.
“Good.” Danny nodded.
You slunk into the house, saying hi to your mom before sinking down into a chair at the kitchen table. You had finally met Neil Hargrove, and he was just as bad as you had heard.
And that’s how he acted in public.
If you didn’t already have an idea of what he was like at home with Billy, you didn’t think you’d be able to imagine it. Neil was a raging douchebag, and in the five seconds he had paid attention to you, you had seen how little he thought of what he saw. Billy had told you snippets, mentioning how his dad thought that surfing and conditioner were for fags and things like cooking and cleaning were women’s work, but actually seeing and hearing the man in person was on an entirely new level.
Your mom tried to make small talk, but all you could think about was breaking Neil Hargrove’s nose. Was that illegal? You’d catch an assault charge if it meant he would fuck off and leave Billy alone. And it would be worth it to see the look on Neil’s face when a girl fought back like that. Wasn’t that the right thing to do? It’s how you always solved your other problems, so why not this one?
…because it might make things worse. You knew that. But at some point, didn’t somebody have to stand up to the bully? You knew Neil was bad. He was probably even worse than you’d heard, if Billy, who was so tough, was scared of him. But Billy was his kid, and you weren’t. You were stupid and angry and you rarely lost a fight, so a big part of you was confident that you could win against Neil.
You considered telling someone. Who could you go to, though? Your family already had some idea, just because of the way Billy always acted around them, but it’s not like they could do that much. Could they? …could anybody? It wasn’t uncommon for dads to be rough with their sons in a town like Hawkins. You figured even if you called the sheriff, there wouldn’t be that much to be done…and Billy would hate it if you did. He would probably hate hearing that you had a run in with his father, too..but that wasn’t your fault. Would it make things worse for Billy, though? …did Neil even know who you were? He didn’t, right?
As the table was set around you and your mom put out some leftovers for dinner, you didn’t budge. You were busy wishing that you had a way to fix things and get Billy away from his dad. Was it your business? Were you trying to intervene in something you shouldn’t? You sort of felt like the moment you helped Billy climb through your window it had become your business, and you weren’t about to back down now.
“God, that guy sucked,” Curt complained as he sat down across from you.
“Curtis, that’s rude,” you mother chastised, taking her own seat again.
“No, I mean it this time.” Curt said. He reached for a drumstick and tore into it, speaking with his mouth full of chicken. “He was all pissin’ and moanin’ because he can’t wait a week for parts we don’t have.”
“It was Billy’s dad.” You spoke up, leaning on your hand as you stared at your empty plate.
“…ah.” You couldn’t see the way that your mom’s usually pleasant expression turned hard.
“I feel bad for the guy,” Curt admitted. “I mean, i see why he’s so pissed off all the time. His dad’s a fuckin’ nightmare.”
“He wouldn’t want you talking about him like that,” you sighed.
“Doesn’t mean it’s not true.”
Yeah, you thought. It sure is true.
“I’m guessing that’s why a certain someone came storming in here.” Your mother said, looking towards you.
“She tried tellin’ him off,” Curt said.
“What was I supposed to do?” You asked, finally looking up. “He was being a dick and he wouldn’t shut up. I mean, it’s obvious he’s got control issues, and he totally hates women—“
“Yeah, that’s why Danny dragged you outta there,” Curt interrupted. “So things wouldn’t get worse.”
You sat back in your chair, grumbling. “I just think somebody should teach him a lesson.”
————————
The next morning, rather than his usual greeting, Billy gave you a harsh glare as he waited for you to get out of your car.
“Good morning to you too,” you said, shutting the door behind you.
“What’s your problem?” He snapped.
“Is this about Max?” You asked, rolling your eyes. “She needed a ride, Billy. I wasn’t about to leave her standing out here in the cold.” Then, you softened your tone. “You didn’t get in trouble, did you?”
His eyes softened slightly, too. “…no. Max didn’t say anything. Susan was still at work when I got home. But Neil…”
You cleared your throat and stood a little taller. “What about him?”
Billy looked down, reaching for your hand and taking it in his. “…practically ripped the front door off its hinges. Came home ranting and shouting about the shitty mechanic and his shitty kids. Especially the girl.”
You could feel anger bubbling up inside your chest. “Your father can kiss my ass.”
He looked back up at you. “I don’t want you talking to him. I don’t want him to even fucking look at you. You understand?”
“I understand that I hate his fucking guts,” you spat. “He can’t go around acting like he’s king of the fucking world. If he can’t even handle a girl telling him to shut up and calm down, then that’s not my problem.”
“Then he’ll make it your problem,” Billy said, voice raised. “Do you fucking get what I’m trying to tell you? Don’t talk to him. Don’t interact with him. I want you to stay as far away from him as possible. And don’t pull your tough guy act with me, Princess.”
“Why not?” You asked stubbornly.
“Because my dad’s not above hitting a woman.”
His words stung. They were as harsh as his glare, scathing, even. But as they sank in, you found yourself uncovering another piece of the Billy Hargrove puzzle, because judging by the look in his eyes, he’d seen Neil hit women before.
And you could guess at least one of them was Billy’s mom.
“…right. I’m sorry.” You tugged on his hand gently, pulling him towards you. “But…do you think we could talk about this? For real?”
Billy wrapped his arms around you, pulling you up against his chest as he mulled it over. He wanted to talk. More than anything. He wanted to tell you about every detail of his life, from his childhood back on the beach to how his morning drive was. But…could he manage that? He knew that you deserved to know everything, and he knew that he trusted you. Because he did. He actually did trust you. But he had never said so many of the words he wanted to, never in his entire life, and he was afraid of saying them out loud.
“…we can try.” He decided.
And that was good enough for you.
“He was a total asshole.” You said as Billy took your bag and slung it over his shoulder. “I mean, he was practically throwing a tantrum over parts he could have ordered himself if he knew what he was doing.”
“…sounds right,” Billy muttered under his breath.
“And he wouldn’t even let Kenny talk. God, he’s such a dick…he called me girl. He’s such a misogynist. I don’t understand how he hasn’t been laid out on the concrete by now.”
“As much as I love the thought, I wanna hear you talk about somethin’ nicer, sweetheart.” Billy said.
It was just about the closest he had ever come to admitting that the topic made him uncomfortable, especially in a public setting, and the sincerity of it had you keeping your mouth shut for a few seconds while you tried to change the subject.
“…I’m failing math.”
“That’s more like it.”
———————————
It went without saying that Billy spent more time at your house than you did at his. In fact, apart from knowing the address, you knew absolutely nothing about the Hargrove residence…and Billy wanted to keep it that way. He always picked you up for dates, he always snuck in through your window, and he always grabbed breakfast with your family when it was an option. Never the other way around.
You knew that he had good reason for it. After seeing Neil Hargrove in the flesh, you didn’t really want to inhabit the same room as him for very long…unless it was because you were beating the shit out of him. Giving him a taste of his own medicine seemed fair, you reasoned, and while Billy changed the subject whenever his father came up in conversation, you were pretty confident that he wouldn’t mind you breaking Neil’s nose. Or…maybe he would. The guy was still his dad, after all. It was easy for you to tell him that he should just move into your house and leave his family behind, but for Billy, who always avoided talking about it, you suspected it was a bit more complicated.
“I hate him.” He mumbled into your chest one night, a week before Valentine’s Day. “So fucking much.”
“I know, baby.” You murmured, hand rubbing circles against his back as he laid on you.
His head was resting on your boobs, one arm wrapped around your waist while the rest of his body laid on your bed. It was midnight, and Billy had woken you up right after you’d managed to fall asleep. When you turned your lamp on, insisting on doing so even though Billy tried to stop you, you didn’t see any black eyes or split lips like part of you was expecting; instead, you saw only his tired, teary eyes, and you were once again struck by how small and vulnerable he looked. During the day, he was fire and rage, like a caged lion. At night, in your arms, he was broken, and you just hoped you could give him a safe enough place to glue the pieces of himself together again.
“Wanna talk about it?” You asked.
Billy was quiet, hesitating for a moment as he thought. “…alright.”
Well, he wasn’t giving you much, but it was the closest he’d gotten so far. “What happened?”
“…Max ran off again.” He heaved a sigh that you could feel throughout your whole body.
“She does that a lot, I’ve noticed.”
“Yeah. Back in California, before we moved, she actually got pretty far once. Cops grabbed her just before she hopped on a bus.” He shifted, resting his cheek on your chest instead of burying his entire face in it. “They blamed me for it.”
“Why?” You scoffed. “It’s not like it’s your fault.”
“Respect and responsibility,” he spat. “I’m older. I’m supposed to keep her safe. I can’t fucking do that when she’s runnin’ around the entire fucking town with Harrington and those other little shits.”
“Why are you two at such odds with each other?” You asked. “I know neither of you asked for this whole family thing, but…I dunno. Feels like it would be easier if you could work together.”
“…we didn’t ask to be stuck with each other and I didn’t ask for a new fucking mother.” Billy growled.
And then it dawned on you.
He never spoke about his mom.
You sat up a little straighter, trying to pull him with you. “Can I, uh…” you cleared your throat. “Can I ask what happened?”
Billy was quiet again. He was staring up at you, brilliant blue eyes alight with cold flames. You wished you knew what was going through his head.
“She left me.” He admitted, looking away.
“What?” You asked. “She just…abandoned you?”
He winced and closed his eyes, and you felt your heart break.
“They weren’t happy. He got worse. So she just…up and left.” He turned his head again and his voice became muffled by your shirt. “I miss her so fucking much.”
Your fingers found his hair and you ran them through it. “How old were you?”
“Not that old.” He mumbled. Then, he managed to move again, resting his cheek against your collarbone as he stared at the wall. “We used to go to the beach together. She’d wear these dresses she always loved and she’d teach me to surf. I’d stay out there all day while she picked out shells or just watched…she fucking loved the ocean.”
“She sounds nice.”
“Yeah.” He let out another massive sigh, practically deflating on top of you. “We would go to this real quiet beach. It was like our special place. But my dad didn’t like me surfing. Said it’s for pussies. The older I got, the more he’d say shit like that.”
“That’s fucking stupid.” You said.
“I don’t even like basketball.” He admitted. “I just like winning.”
“Is that why you’re so good at it?” You grinned, trying to lighten the atmosphere a little. “I mean, you totally humiliate Steve Harrington whenever you play. You’re like, the best on the team.”
He snorted a laugh. “Guess i practice hard because I hope it’ll make me like it. Hasn’t really worked yet.”
“…oh.” You frowned. “…there’s not much in the way of beaches around here…I guess you can kinda surf on Lake Michigan sometimes, but it wouldn’t be the same…”
“I gotta get back to California.” He said.
“Is that your plan?” You asked. “After graduation?”
“Yeah. I mean…it was.” He glanced up at you. “You could come.”
Your heart leapt. “I’ve never been to the west coast at all.”
“I’ll take you. I’ll work. Get some money. Then we can go.”
He sounded so desperate, so sincere, that you knew he believed it could happen. “…maybe. We’ll see.”
“You’d love California, Princess.” He said.
“I’d only go if you promised to teach me to surf.”
He looked at you. “…deal.”
You smiled and grabbed his arm, tugging on him. He got the hint and pushed himself up, crawling over you until he could lean his forehead against yours. His arms were caging you in, his body hovering over yours in a suggestive way that was anything but. This was more like the Billy you saw during the day—protective, big, strong. He was still so soft, though, far from the prickly and easily angered guy he was in front of Tommy and Carol.
This was your Billy.
Your hands slipped around the back of his neck to tangle in his hair. He smelled so good, like him, and he was so warm you wanted to curl up and sleep. He was so still. So calm. So quiet. The rage was gone for the night, leaving in its wake a tired, emotionally exhausted boy who didn’t know what to do with himself.
“You spending the night?” You asked.
“…yeah.” He rolled to the side, the bed bouncing gently under his weight. “If that’s cool.”
“Of course,” you said as you reached to turn the lamp off. “I like sleeping with you.”
“You haven’t even tried that yet,” he grinned, grabbing your hip and pulling you back against him.
“…i like sleeping next to you.”
“I think you’d like the other version more…”
You wiggled back into him, smiling to yourself as you felt his chest on your back. His hand was soft, holding you gently as he pressed a kiss against your neck. He was eager, and you knew that his flirting was more than just pretty words. But at the same time, you got the feeling that he wasn’t hoping for anything more than a night of cuddling. Because even though he refused to admit it, Billy Hargrove was a sucker for a warm embrace and a quiet, cozy bed.
“I wanna stay like this forever.” You sighed.
“Yeah.” Billy said, laying his head down on your pillow and burying his face in the back of your neck. “Me too.”
You couldn’t stay like that forever, but you could at least stay there until morning. Billy was back out the window before dawn, giving you a long kiss before setting off. Sometimes he drove to see you, but more often than not, he walked across Hawkins, using it as a chance to think.
You always watched him go, leaning in your open window and wishing he could stay. Sometimes, he left things for you—a shirt, an earring—but this morning, you were left with nothing but his fading scent as you climbed back into bed. It wasn’t enough, but it was all you had, so you buried your face in your pillow and pulled the sheets as tightly around yourself as you could before drifting off.
When you woke again, your hand brushed something cold. There, between the sheets, was the gold chain he always wore around his neck, and you knew he hadn’t left it on purpose. He always wore it, almost never taking it off, and upon closer inspection, you saw that the clasp had simply come undone. Nothing was broken, at least…but you needed to get it back to him before he realized and got pissed off, which, knowing Billy, would probably happen before noon. 
Unfortunately, it was Saturday, which meant you wouldn’t be able to just meet him at Hawkins High and give it to him then. Unless he randomly appeared at your place over the weekend, he’d be waiting until Monday…and he wasn’t exactly known for his patience. You could imagine him irritated and stressed about it, and it would just be one more layer added to his problems. Of course, you could alleviate that by simply going to his place to drop it off…
…but it was Saturday morning. Which meant that there was a good chance his parents were home.
You sat up, holding the chain in your hand as you mulled it over. This was perfectly innocent. All you wanted to do was bring his jewelry back to him. It was a nice chain, too nice for you to be holding on to for very long. You didn’t trust yourself—or your brothers—not to break it somehow on accident. And besides, were you really afraid of Neil Hargrove?
No. 
You weren’t.
Maybe you should have been, but you weren’t. As you got out of bed and changed out of your pajamas, you felt like you were on a mission, and after a quick breakfast, you were running to the car with Billy’s chain safely tucked away in your pocket.
“Excuse me, missy.” Something suddenly caught you by the hood of your jacket, yanking you back violently. “Where’re you going so early on a Saturday?”
You twisted to see your brother. “Fuck off, Curt.”
“Not til you tell me.”
You squirmed, struggling helplessly in his grip. “…fine. Billy left something here and I’m going to return it. Happy?”
“…you’re going to his place?” Curt asked.
“Is that not what I just—“
“I call shotgun.”
He let you go with a shove, stepping around you as he walked off towards the Barracuda. You were left staring after him in shock for a few seconds before you sprinted to catch up, just barely beating him to the car and hopping in before he could.
“Get out.” You said as you slammed your door.
He was making himself comfortable in the passenger seat, already grabbing for his seatbelt. “No way, shrimp. You’re not going there without backup.”
“Who said anything about needing backup?”
He gave you a skeptical look. “I’ve known you almost two decades now. You think I can’t tell when my baby sister is planning something stupid?”
“I don’t need your help, Curt.” You growled, starting the car.
“Would you just shut up and drive?” He snapped. “Look, I know you’re about to go knock on that front door and try to fist fight Neil Hargrove. Hell, I’d like to see you land a hit or two on that asshole, especially since we finally got his car taken care of and he’s out of the shop. But I’m not about to let you go there all alone, dipshit.”
“I won’t be alone,” you argued as you pulled out onto the street. “Billy will be there.”
“Billy is scared shitless of that man,” Curt said. “You think I can’t see that? I can’t even blame him. If Dad acted like that, we’d all be way more fucked up, too. There was this guy I graduated with, name was Frank, ‘n his old man was a hard ass too—“
Your brother continued but you were zoning out as you drove. It was nice to have him along for the ride, even if he was your most annoying sibling, and as you drew closer and closer to Cherry Lane, you were growing more and more glad that he had decided to come along.
This time, you pulled right up to the house. If anybody inside was near a window, you were sure they’d be able to hear the rumble of the engine. For a moment, you considered running—Billy could wait a couple days, couldn’t he?—but then you thought about how badly you wanted to give Neil Hargrove a piece of your mind, and you steeled yourself.
“Don’t start anything,” Curt warned as you opened your door.
“I won’t.” You said. “Promise.”
He stayed in the car, keeping an eye on you as you marched up to the house. It was almost hard to believe that Billy lived in something so normal, though you figured he probably wasn’t very fond of it. As you reached out to knock on the door, you hoped that he was awake, because seeing his face would make this a lot better than not.
Billy was awake, just barely. He had made it back through his bedroom window before anyone could notice his absence and had managed to doze off, but at the sound of someone banging on the front door, he was groggily sitting up.
At the sound of Neil saying “Who the hell—you.”, Billy was on high alert.
And at the muffled sound of a feminine voice that he recognized instantly, he was up on his feet, grabbing a pair of sweats and a tank, and exiting his bedroom as quickly and as quietly as he could.
“—I just wanted to swing by and give Billy something he dropped at school yesterday,” you half-lied, hands held behind your back as you tried to look as innocent as possible.
Neil wasn’t buying it.
“How the hell do you know where he lives?” Neil growled. “Been here before?”
Your eye twitched and your hands tightened into fists behind your back, but you reminded yourself that you had literally just promised not to start a fight, and did what you could to swallow your anger.
“It’s a small town.” you shrugged. “Everybody knows where everybody lives.”
Neil leaned forward slightly, trying to make himself seem larger. He was a big guy, he really was--he took up the entire doorway, and you could see that Billy got his broad shoulders from his father--but you were determined not to show fear. If you did, then he’d think he could push you around. And he absolutely could not.
“What exactly did my boy drop that was so important you needed to hand deliver it?” he asked, hand still on the door as if he was prepared to slam it shut at any moment.
“…is he home?” You asked. “I would rather just give it to him directly if that’s cool.”
“You can give it to me.”
You did your best not to make a face. “Mr. Hargrove, I would really rather—“
“Give it to me.” He interrupted, holding his hand out. “Now.”
Your already short fuse had just about burnt out. As your eyes flicked down to his expectant palm, you felt more annoyed than you had in a long, long time, and when you met his gaze once more, your peaceful and reasonable facade had already dropped.
“Mr. Hargrove,” you growled, “I’m gonna ask again. Is Billy home?”
The tone in your voice shocked both Billy and his father. For Neil, it was rage inducing, but for Billy, it was awe inspiring…and worrying. He felt frozen in place, unable to take even a single step towards the door. He could feel himself shutting down as his father’s demeanor grew more tense, but at the same time, Billy was desperate to get to you, because he knew what Neil was capable of and you didn’t.
Somehow, he willed his legs to move, and you suddenly saw him appear just behind his father. Your gaze softened at the sight of him, and you half smiled.
“Hey.” You said, looking past Neil as you finally pulled out the necklace that has started all this. “You left this.”
Those three simple, innocent words made Neil Hargrove snap.
He looked back to see Billy standing there, looking like a deer in the headlights with those big, wide eyes that Neil hated but you loved. Then, Neil looked back towards you, and he was even angrier than he had been when his car was in the shop.
“You’re one of his fucking whores, aren’t you?” He sneered. “I shoulda known. He always did know how to pick ‘em. Get the fuck off my property.”
“But I didn’t—“
“You think I fucking care if he gets that stupid chain back?” Neil scoffed. “You ask me, he’s better off without that faggot shit.”
Billy winced, a movement that did not go unnoticed by you.
“Before I go, can I ask you something, Mr. Hargrove?” You said, eyes still on Billy as you put the necklace back in your pocket.
You were vaguely aware of Neil grunting in response. Your focus shifted back to him.
“…why the hell are you such a bully?”
Billy’s eyes widened in alarm at the same time as Neil’s narrowed in anger.
“Excuse me?” The latter snarled.
“You heard me.” You said, voice raised, mustering as much of that brazen, stupid courage as you could. “You’re a big fucking bully and you always have been and you always will be.”
“You’ve got a lotta nerve—“
“I do!” You snapped, glaring up at him so harshly that he should have crumbled into dust. “I do have a lotta nerve because I’m sick and tired of the way that you beat the shit out of the only son you have!”
Neil’s expression was darkening like storm clouds. “He went crying to you?”
“He didn’t have to.” You sneered.
Billy could see the way his father’s arms were flexing and it threw him into a panic. He recognized the movement. He could see the signs. Neil was deciding whether or not he should beat the tar out of you, whether or not it was worth being known as the guy who beat the mechanic’s daughter.
You could see it, too, only you didn’t panic.
“You put one fucking hand on me and I’ll knock every last tooth out of your ugly skull.” You spat.
Billy couldn’t believe what he was hearing, but he didn’t have time to worry about that, because Neil was starting to move and Billy had to do something.
“Hey!” He finally barked, seizing a fistful of his father’s shirt and yanking him back.
It was the last thing Neil expected, and he lost his grip on the door as he stumbled backwards. Billy took the opportunity to slip past him, standing with his back to you as if it was his job to act as a shield, and by the time Neil collected himself enough to circle back, you were already trying to wiggle around Billy to get at least one good shot in.
Neil ignored you, though. That might have been the worst part, that he actually ignored you and went for Billy instead, grabbing a handful of his shirt and pulling him forward. With Billy, he didn’t have to consider whether or not hitting him was a good idea. With Billy, everything was on the table.
And Billy was bracing himself, because he was prepared to take whatever his father threw at him.
“This is the kinda shit you’ve been hanging around with?” Neil hissed in his son’s face. “What happened to that respect and responsibility we talked about, son?”
“Leave her alone.” Billy managed to say, jaw clenched.
“Yeah? Or what?”
“Or you’re gonna have a lot more to deal with than just her.” A new voice growled from behind you.
You already knew it was Curt intervening before things could get worse, but Billy had to twist his head to look back. When he saw who was standing there, he was surprised, because Curtis was the last person he ever expected to come to his rescue.
Something in your brother’s expression must have been enough to seriously worry Neil, because his grip on Billy loosened and he let him go with a rough shove.
“Get out of my fucking sight.”
“With pleasure.” Billy sneered, staring him down.
“Come on.” You mumbled, grabbing his wrist and tugging him off the porch.
As you led him to the car, Billy felt himself starting to lose it.
When the doors had shut and the three of you were driving away, he lost it.
“What the hell is wrong with you two?” He shouted, tears blurring the edges of his eyes.
“Don’t look at me,” Curt growled as he drove.
“Neil started it.” You grumbled, folding your arms over your chest and slumping down. “He’s such a dick, I can’t believe—“
“How the hell do you expect me to go back there now? Huh?” Billy yelled, voice cracking and shaking in a way you had never heard before. “Did you even fucking think about that? That I fucking live there? You know what you just did? You just made that house a living hell for me!”
You suddenly felt a pit forming in your stomach. “…oh…”
“See? You didn’t think. You didn’t listen to me. I told you to stay away from him and instead you do—do—whatever the hell that was!”
“Hey!” Curt snapped. “Would you can it for a second?”
“And why the hell are you here?” Billy asked. “You don’t even fucking like me—“
“Don’t put words in my mouth!” Your brother suddenly slammed the brakes, then turned to glare at Billy. “Look. You’re not goin’ back there. Not without one of us around. Got it?”
Billy’s lip curled up in a sneer. “Stay out of my business—“
“I’m not finished.” He growled. “You’re stayin’ away for a couple days. Minimum. And don’t say that I don’t fucking like you when I just tagged along on this stupid ride to make sure you both came out of it in one piece.”
Billy wasn’t sure what to say. That was probably the nicest think Curt, your grumpiest brother, had ever said to him, and as he continued mumbling and swearing to himself, he seemed genuine.
You, however, seemed guilty.
“Billy…”
“No.” He sighed, leaning his head back, “no. Thanks.”
“…for what?”
He ran a hand through his hair and let out a laugh, releasing some of his nervousness now that he could maybe begin calming down. “I’ve never seen anybody talk to him like that.”
“She’s tough as nails,” Curt piped up as he drove off again.
“I know.” Billy sighed. “I definitely know.”
————————
“Hey, handsome. You ready?”
Billy grinned at you. “Shouldn’t i be asking you that, Princess?”
You smiled up at him. He was wearing his favorite red dress shirt and a nice pair of jeans, an earring dangling from his ear lobe and his gold chain visible around his neck. It was finally Valentines Day, and it was time for Billy to show you what he’d been planning.
“I guess so,” you smiled as he took your hand and led you toward the door. “But I am.”
“Then let’s fuckin’ go already.”
His Camaro was waiting outside, just as it had been almost every day since the Neil incident. Just like Curt had ordered, Billy had been staying on your couch—and in your bed, once everyone else was asleep—and far away from his house for the last several days, only stopping there to get things that he needed and check up on Max. So far, Neil wasn’t aiming his anger towards her, but neither you nor Billy were convinced that it would stay that way forever.
Billy was happy living on your couch, though. Sure, there were a lot of awkward things about it—like knowing your brothers were constantly around and having to cover for them whenever they snuck girls home—but compared to living with his dad, it was heaven.
A heaven that paid, even.
Your dad had Billy helping out in the garage after school, and he was a fast learner. He gave him a little cash under the table, too, and tonight, as Billy pulled into one of Hawkins’ nicest restaurants, you finally saw what he was planning on spending it all on.
“Oh, Billy,” you said as he took your hand and led you inside, “this is too nice. No way.”
“Don’t be stupid,” Billy said in that taunting way that you knew was loving, “my girl deserves the best. ‘N pretty soon, you’ll be eating like this every night. Watch.”
“You know, I’m perfectly fine with burgers and shakes, too,” you laughed.
He stopped just outside the door, smiling down at you. “I know, doll. But lemme spoil you, just for tonight. Yeah?”
You bit your lip, grinning up at him. “…yeah.”
And he took your face in his hands and leaned down to kiss you, and you twisted your fingers into his curls, and you admitted to yourself that you loved, you fucking loved, the glorious mess that was Billy Hargrove.
1K notes
·
View notes