in view of Netflix and a few other networks apparently announcing that they are no longer requiring actors to wear corsets/stays, but framing it as the ultimate in feminist allyship against an Oppressive Historical Torture-Garment (and presumably typing their press releases one-handed, if you catch my drift), I have a few things to say:
1. I presume they will also be condemning Spanx, dieting, weight loss surgery, obsessive exercise, breast or pectoral or ab implants, Flat Tummy Tea, editing actors’ bodies in post, etc. since this is all about promoting healthy body image. ...right?
2. Okay, this one is not tongue-in-cheek: if a costume designer forces you to wear massively uncomfortable stays or corsets and tells you your discomfort is an inherent feature of that garment type, they are lying. All the articles on this cited reports from actresses saying they threw up because of Regency stays or couldn’t eat in Edwardian corsets. And while I’m sure some of that is giving interview audiences the sensationalism they want to hear, I believe them in general.
Someone needs to tell them that that’s not normal.
I have worn corsets and stays a lot in my life. I know people who wear them as everyday support garments. And neither I nor anyone I know has been seriously hindered in normal activities by them. There are even photos and videos of women from corset-intensive eras climbing glaciers, playing sports, having snowball fights, doing manual labor...living their lives
Sure, there have always been and will always be people who find corsets or stays inherently uncomfortable- that’s why it’s good to have many support garment options available for people who need them. And there have always been and will always be ill-made, ill-fitting, or extreme examples of the type- I’m not saying corsets are always The Most Comfortable Thing Ever For Everyone, because that’s not universally true of any garment.
But these production companies have been hurting actresses under the guise of “historical accuracy,” and this latest pronouncement is just another attempt to shift the blame.
Don’t let them get away with it.
EDIT: Apparently the Official nature of the source for this announcement is in question, but the gist of the post still stands, so I’m leaving it up. Will edit further if new developments arise.
3K notes
·
View notes
Period dramas dresses tournament: Green dresses FINALS- Lucrezia Borgia, The Borgias (gifset) vs Chandramukhi, Devdas (gifset)
Propaganda for Chandramukhi's dress
175 notes
·
View notes
The wedding dress of Elisabeth “Sisi” in Bavaria in TV and Film
Romy Schneider in Sissi (1955)
Cristiana Capotondi in Sisi (2009)
Dominique Devenport in Sisi (2021)
Devrim Lingnau in The Empress (2022)
2K notes
·
View notes
the thing about skirts- especially long skirts -being portrayed as inherently impractical is that it completely ignores context.
I wear long skirts a lot in my everyday life. would I hike the Rockies in them? no- although technically one can, because women in particular did for many years. but I’m not hiking the Rockies every day. I’m a museum worker living in a large city. as long as I can walk without treading on my skirt’s hem, and avoid getting it too dirty in a way I can’t clean, I’m fine.
if I were going to hike the Rockies, I would wear something different. just like I don’t wear my Natural Form evening gown with a train to trek to the subway in a rainstorm
situational clothing has existed for a long time, in many cultures the world over. in my specific era/area of focus (Europe and colonized North America during the 19th-early 20th centuries) you get ground-clearing skirts intended for long periods of walking, or even shorter ones worn by women doing serious physical labor. some occupational outfits, like those of Victorian England’s famous female coal-pit workers, even involve a hiked skirt and trousers. but you can find photos of the same women in more conventional attire for the era, because what they wore to church was not what they wore to work was not what they wore to run errands for their families in their free time
so when movies are like “oh my god Female Lead can’t FUNCTION in these skirts!!!” (painted not as a personal preference for the character, but as a Universal Shortcoming of Skirts) and all she’s doing is walking around town in skirts of a reasonable length...head meet desk
1K notes
·
View notes
Period dramas dresses tournament: Green dresses Round 3- Group A: Princess Margaret, The crown vs Bertha Russell, The gilded age (gifset)
183 notes
·
View notes