Pureblood Purists Actually Have Valid Concerns
Disclaimers
Before I start my post let me make 2 disclaimers since some people have a tendency to twist words on Tumblr:
Not all blood purists were death eaters. I am not condoning DE terrorism here. I am referring to people who held pureblood beliefs but never fought in a war to oppress people.
Harry Potter is a fictional world. My arguments are not meant to be extended to the real world.
Assumption about Magic
JKR does not specify the origin of magic. Is it like ATLA where it's a spiritual kind of thing and people are blessed by Lady Magic? Or is it a gene thing and wizards are a subspecies of human? For me, I am going to go with magic being a gene thing. If magic was like bending in ATLA then wizards should not be such a tiny minority.
Missed Potential of Umbridge Interrogation Scene
This post was inspired by Book 7, Chapter 13 – The Muggle-born Registration Commission. Specifically, the part where Umbridge is interrogating this poor muggle-borne woman named Mrs Cattermole.
‘Could you please tell us from which witch or wizard you took that wand?’
Umbridge's line of questioning is so ridiculous and JKR missed a golden opportunity to introduce some nuance here. She paints all purebloods who are not blood traitors as evil/bigoted. Just because this is a kid's book it does not mean she has to treat kids like idiots. Instead of painting purebloods as bigoted fools who believe magic can be stolen or sadists making up crack in this sham kangaroo court, she could have used this dialogue to present valid and ignored concerns of purebloods. Instead of crap like this, the Voldemort regime could be jailing purebloods who married muggles or mugglebornes on the count of them diluting their race. Or maybe firing half-bloods and mugglebornes and giving those jobs to purebloods. These actions are still wrong but at least they would be rational and add some depth. And purebloods have serious cause for concern. Let me point out 5.
Concern 1 - Existence of Squibs
In the books, we don't know the blood status of the parents of prominent squibs like Filch. But I bet the likelihood of your kid being a squib increases dramatically if one of the parents is muggleborne.
It makes sense to me that mugglebornes could be descendants of squibs. Making mugglebornes basically muggles who won the genetic lottery. In book 2 I think, Arthur claimed Granger was a historical wizard figure and asked Hermione if she bore a relation to him. She denies this but what if someone in the Granger family was a squib in the past and years later she got lucky?? So basically if you mate with a muggleborne, you are basically reproducing with a muggle. Which in turn increases the chances of a squib kid. Squibs can't function in the magic world properly.
Concern 2 - Wizards are a minority
Wizards are a minority in a muggle majority. It's a fact that minorities are wiped out when they reproduce with the majority.
Hagrid says this in book 2:
“Dirty blood, see. Common blood. It’s mad. Most wizards these days are half-blood anyway. If we hadn’t married Muggles we’d’ve died out.”
If Hagrid is right and most wizards are half-blood, how is this a good thing? Given enough time, if wizards keep diluting their race like this by reproducing with muggles, the wizard minority will slowly be erased which leads to...
Concern 3 - Cultural Erasure
It's more than just blood dilution but loss of tradition. Even if a muggleborne like Hermione integrates into the wizarding world, she will never truly grasp certain customs and traditions that pureblood families like the Weasleys and Malfoys will. For example, I came to the US for college. Even though I have been here for half a decade now, I will never understand what it is like to grow up as a kid in the US. I don't appreciate US holidays like Thanksgiving and Memorial Day. My kid likely will but they will have to learn those customs from an external source or maybe my future husband's family. Someone like Hermione may even see some pureblood/wizarding traditions as archaic and unnecessary. Over time, wizards will lose their culture and practically become muggles with magic. Which is why Hermione being minister of magic sometimes leaves a sour taste in my mouth. There's a reason why only born citizens can become president/prime minister for countries like the US (I would like to believe there is a reason anyway).
Concern 4 - Reproductive Issues?
Also, why did wizards need muggles to survive in the first place? Were the women/men having fertility issues? Was the wizarding population so minuscule that they were inbreeding? Or were they simply just horny for muggles? If small native/African tribes are/were able to survive without reproducing with white invaders or other outsiders why is it different for wizards??
Concern 5 - Lack of New Blood
Still focusing on Hagrid's quote. Let's say every pureblood family started with a muggleborne wizard/witch. Therefore given enough generations, Granger could theoretically become a pureblood name like Malfoy or Weasley. But there's a problem: there aren't enough mugglebornes!
Read Hagrid's quote carefully. He said wizards would have died out if they did not intermarry with muggles. Not that wizards would have died out without mugglebornes adding to the population!
This further adds to my blood dilution argument. Basically, we have a fixed magical gene pool which is being stretched every generation with more and more half-bloods being popped out.
Conclusion
Pureblood purists have rational reasons to favour blood purity and to be frustrated with "blood traitors". As more pureblood families like the Weasleys intermarry with muggles/mugglebornes, there is an ever-smaller marriage pool for purebloods. Throw in cultural dilution too.
If JKR wanted to add depth to the muggleborne discrimination, she should have shown how mugglebornes are critical to the survival of wizarding kind and how much purebloods actually need them. Maybe show them using their muggle knowledge to improve wizarding society while she's at it too? But it's like muggebornes like Lily and Hermione have amnesia and forget all about their muggle background! At least make wizards reap the benefit of magic and technology to balance out the issues of reproducing with mugglebornes and muggles.
I just wish JKR could have given purebloods more of a voice. Not all purebloods are crazy, bloodthirsty DEs or Dumbledore bootlickers. And oftentimes, there are reasons behind discrimination that should be examined and explored, instead of just demonized. Harry Potter is seven books worth of wasted potential. I don't know how anyone can say JKR was excellent at world building when the wizarding world feels so tiny and incomplete.
49 notes
·
View notes
Chapter 1: Department of Mysteries
—
Masterlist
Prologue
—
"Department of Mysteries," the voice announced as the lift stopped.
June 18, 1996
The teenagers didn't know what to expect as they stepped out, all frightened but putting up a brave face.
Hermione Granger, the brightest witch of her age, was ready to stand by her best friend's side, ready to face whatever lay ahead as a true Gryffindor would do.
"This is it," Harry breathed out, forcing himself to sound brave for his friends.
They started taking small but determined steps towards the door in front of them, with Harry leading the way through the corridor.
Hermione silently walked right behind Harry. Her heart was pounding against her chest, and her hands were becoming sweaty.
"Okay, listen," Harry's voice pulled everyone out of their own thoughts as he stopped before reaching the door. "Maybe...," he hesitated. "Maybe a couple of people should stay here as a lookout and—"
Yet, he didn't get to finish his sentence as Ginny, clearly fed up with Harry's hero act, interrupted him.
Hermione chose to let her friends deal with Harry, thankful that Ginny, Neville, and Ron took the initiative to put Harry in his place.
The brunette girl took a deep breath as she watched Harry turning the knob of the door, pushing it open.
—
"Lumos!" Harry said as the tip of his wand started glowing.
"Lumos!" Hermione and Ron followed Harry's lead.
Hermione looked around, scared at the darkness surrounding her.
Here it was cold, too cold for her liking, and it made her involuntarily shiver.
Hermione wasn't sure what she expected to find, but she clearly wasn't expecting to see thousands of shelves filled up with countless crystal globes covered in dust.
She briefly looked to her left and noticed that Ron was as scared and confused as she was, and there was no doubt that Harry felt the same way.
A rumbling sound broke the eerie silence, and all six members of the Order let out a soft gasp.
The door they had just finished walking in through started moving, as the walls started rotating.
'Clever move,' Hermione thought. 'They don't want us to know which door we came in through.'
The girl slowly turned her head to look at Harry, at the same time as Ron did, and the three teenagers shared a look of concern before Harry started to speed walk through the shelves, hoping to find the same row number he saw in his vision, praying that they would arrive in time to save Sirius.
—
"You said it was row ninety-seven," Hermione whispered to Harry, waiting for confirmation.
"Yeah," Harry breathed out, and she watched him lean forward to have a better look at the end of the closest row.
Hermione looked around, her mind racing a thousand miles per hour as she squinted her eyes to the next row.
"We need to go right, I think," whispered Hermione again as she tried to read the number of the row. "Yes," she mumbled once she spotted something. "That's fifty-four."
Harry quickly took off, almost running, as everyone else did the same.
—
"Ninety-seven!" Hermione whisper-shouted, being the first to spot the number they had so desperately searched for.
The bright witch watched with bated breath as Harry stretched out his hand towards a globe that Neville had pointed out to have Harry's name on its tag.
"Harry," Hermione warned sharply, as she felt something was not right about this globe. "I don't think you should touch it!"
But her warnings fell on deaf ears as Harry picked up the globe, ignoring her.
She internally rolled her eyes in annoyance at Harry's behavior, but her attention quickly turned to the small bluish globe that suddenly lit up when her friend held it.
She couldn't shake off the feeling that something bad was about to happen.
The silence that enveloped this mysterious room was too weird.
And just then, from the corner of her eye, Hermione caught some movement and she knew that what she feared was true.
Everything was a trap.
"Harry!" She urgently called her friend, pulling him out of his trance.
Harry immediately lunged forward, putting himself in between the imminent danger and his friends.
"Where's Sirius?" Hermione heard Harry demand.
"You know..." A deep voice echoed in the silence, making Hermione sharply turn her head towards the masked Death Eater that kept getting dangerously too close to them. "You should really learn to make the difference between dreams," The figure clothed in black, its face hidden by a mask, finally stopped, only to pull out a wand and with a wave, reveal itself to them. "And reality. You only saw what the Dark Lord wanted you to see."
Hermione allowed a soft gasp to escape her lips.
The Death Eater in front of them was none other than Lucius Malfoy.
The teenagers stiffened their shoulders, their shaky hands tightly gripping their wands.
"Now hand me the prophecy," demanded the old Malfoy.
"You do anything to us and I'll break it!" Harry threatened, hoping that this would buy them enough time to devise a plan.
Suddenly, a sickening, sweet voice, filled with evil intentions, laughed.
"He knows how to play!" Laughed the female voice. "Itsy-Bitty... Baby." The figure stepped out of the darkness, her steps accompanied by the sounds of heels. "Potter!" She finished in a mocking tone.
Hermione didn't like how insanely sweet that voice sounded and the girl felt her blood freeze in her veins as she recognized the face in front of them from the Daily Prophet, yet she still took a moment to have a good look at the woman's features.
She had long, jet-black hair with untamed curls, adding to her appearance that made her look insane. Her skull-like face did little to betray the spark of life in her dark eyes. It was as if the Dark Lord had raised her from the dead to serve him, but Hermione knew it was more than that, as her pale skin was a stark contrast to her crimson red lips.
Despite her thin, Azkaban-shaped physique, Hermione could easily imagine this woman as a stunning beauty in her youthful years.
"Bellatrix Lestrange," Neville growled, moving forward from behind Hermione's back.
The shock on his face was clear as day, even in the dimness of the room, upon seeing Bellatrix Lestrange standing before him in the flesh.
"Neville Longbottom, is it?" Bellatrix faked curiosity as if she didn't already know who he is. "How's Mum and Dad?" She asked, a sadistic smile appearing on her face.
It was as if she took pleasure in tormenting the poor boy who lost his parents because of Bellatrix.
And in Bellatrix's eyes, Hermione saw the fire of hate and anger burning deep within them.
Hermione couldn't comprehend why Bellatrix hated Neville so much.
"Better now that they're about to be avenged," Hermione heard Neville growl again as the Longbottom boy lifted his wand, ready to attack.
But before things could escalate further, Harry was quick to hold Neville back, as Lucius did the same with Bellatrix.
Harry pushed Neville back, and as he did, his right foot stepped on Hermione's toes.
"Ah..." Hermione sharply took a breath in, looking down at her foot before leaning closer to Harry. "What?" She quietly questioned her friend.
"Now, let's everybody just calm down," Lucius raised his arms, trying to calm the tense atmosphere. "Shall we? All we want is that prophecy."
"What?" Urged Hermione before Lucius could finish his speech.
"Why did Voldemort need me to come and get this?" Harry inquired, pretending he hadn't heard Hermione.
"You dare speak his name?" Gasped Bellatrix. "You filthy half-blood!" She shouted, making Hermione flinch.
'There's no doubt she's insane,' Hermione internally chuckled, keeping her thoughts to herself.
"It's alright," Lucius once again tried to maintain some semblance of peace. "He's just a curious lad," he said, looking Harry dead in the eyes. "Aren't you?"
Harry turned his head, pretending to avoid Lucius' gaze. "Smash shelves..." he hissed.
Hermione's eyes widened as she understood the message.
"When I say go..." Harry continued, careful not to reveal what he was doing to the Death Eaters.
"Prophecies can only be retrieved by those whom they are made," the elder Malfoy continued, interrupting Harry, "which is lucky for you, really."
Hermione took advantage of the distraction provided by Lucius' speech as she turned to the person on her right, who happened to be Ginny, to pass down the message.
"Smash shelves when Harry says to," Hermione whispered to Ginny, making a sign with her hand for her to pass down the message to the rest, to which Ginny answered with a short nod.
"Haven't you always wondered what was the reason for the connection between you and the Dark Lord, hm?" hummed Lucius.
Hermione slightly jumped, scared, when from different sides, more masked Death Eaters stepped out of the shadows.
They were being circled, with no way to escape.
She should have guessed that they wouldn't leave this place without a fight.
'Wonderful,' she thought, trying to distract herself from the fear that threatened to overwhelm her.
She scanned their surroundings, quickly trying to come up with a plan to escape.
Hermione didn't hear the rest of the conversation between Lucius and Harry, her mind focused on the possible outcomes as the Death Eater in front of her kept getting dangerously too close to her.
She could hear her heart pounding in her ears, awaiting Harry's signal.
And just then, Harry's yell reached her ears.
"Now!" shouted Potter.
"Reducto!" Hermione yelled, her hand reflexively shooting the spell towards a shelf.
"Run!" yelled Harry again, and they all took off running as the shelves started to collapse.
The next moments were a chaotic blur for Hermione as she and her friends tried to avoid falling shelves and crystal globes from hitting their heads.
She cast spells left and right, only registering a frightened "Stupefy!" she shouted when she saw a Death Eater grabbing Harry's shoulder.
Next thing she knew, the brunette witch was falling 20 feet through the air, while the screams of her friends filled her ears.
"Arresto Momentum!" Hermione screamed, waving her wand through the air.
Then, she felt her body coming to an abrupt stop right before hitting the ground.
She let out a grunt when she was finally dropped face-forward but at the same time, she let out a long sigh of relief.
She was thankful that her quick thinking saved her life and her friends' lives.
Again.
She looked around, allowing her heightened senses to calm down for the moment, as she confusedly assimilated her surroundings.
Hermione's frown only deepened when she heard Harry mumble something as he started to walk towards a weird stone archway that was so conveniently placed in the middle of the room.
"Careful!" warned Hermione in a hushed whisper.
She was afraid this was another trick of the Death Eaters to get their hands on Harry's prophecy.
"Let's go," she urged again when she saw Harry ignoring her warnings. "This isn't right, Harry, come on, let's go..."
She followed him up the archway's stairs, stopping halfway, too scared to continue.
Yet Harry showed no signs of listening to her.
'He couldn't be that stupid, could he?'
"Harry, let's go, okay?" she kept pleading with him, fear overwhelming her instinct to go there and grab him by his hand and drag him away from there.
"Okay," the boy finally agreed.
Hermione exhaled relieved, but her relief was short-lived when Harry made no move to walk away from the archway.
It was as if he could hear and see something she couldn't, and Merlin, that was annoying.
"What are you saying?" Harry asked loudly, his gaze not leaving the archway.
"Nobody's talking, Harry!" Hermione had enough of this silly game of Harry's.
She pushed aside any lingering fear she might have had and moved towards him.
Harry's claiming of hearing whispers coming from the archway was concerning, to say the least, and it was creeping Hermione out.
"I can hear them too," Luna agreed with Harry, "there are people in there."
'You can't be serious!' Hermione thought annoyed, desperate to find a way to get Harry and Luna back in their right minds. 'That if they ever were in their right mind!' Hermione mentally added.
"What do you mean 'in there'?" Hermione angrily demanded, too sick of this. "There isn't any 'in there', it's just an archway, there's no room for anybody to be there — Harry, stop it, come away —"
With one swift move, she grabbed his arm, surprised to feel him resist her, not budging to move a single inch.
"Harry, we are supposed to be here for Sirius!" she used Sirius as a last resource.
And she was pleased to notice that the mention of Sirius had sparked something inside of Harry as he said, "Let's go."
She must have relaxed too soon because, out of nowhere, a black fog enveloped them, and she heard the unmistakable laugh of none other than Bellatrix Lestrange.
Hermione tried to fight against the fog, she really did, but when a whisper was heard, she froze in fear, unable to think of at least one spell to defend herself.
"You're next, Mudblood." The voice of Bellatrix whispered in her ear, making Hermione shiver.
—
Hermione found herself on her knees on the cold, stone floor, a hand tangled in her curls.
The young witch let out a whimper as she tried to move her head and free herself from what she guessed was the grip of a Death Eater but stopped when pain darted through her skull.
She was terrified, she isn't going to lie.
Her eyes scanned the scene that was unfolding while tiny whimpers escaped her lips, and she saw all of her friends, except Harry, were held in place by a Death Eater, unable to interfere with what was happening between Harry and Lucius.
Hermione had no choice but to watch with widened eyes the chaos unfolding as Sirius showed up out of nowhere just to punch that greasy-haired Malfoy, Aurors appearing as well to save them, and the prophecy getting smashed.
Hermione's breath came out in short ranges as she fearlessly threw herself into the fight that was unfolding.
Right after dodging a "Crucio!" casted by Bellatrix in her direction, she spotted Harry and Neville fighting side by side, having some troubles.
"Crazy witch," Hermione mumbled as she ran towards her male friends. "Stupefy!" she shouted, finally catching up with the two boys, the red jet of light hitting a Death Eater.
Spells and curses were flying in all directions, but the Muggle-born girl tried to ignore it, letting it be just background noise for her ears.
"Impedimenta!" a triumphant cry echoed, and Hermione felt herself being knocked off her feet backwards.
She groaned in pain as she tried to regain her bearings, the safety of Harry and Neville filling her mind before her own.
"We got him!" a man yelled, pulling Hermione out of her confused state.
She turned her head towards the voice, her eyes growing wider as she saw a Death Eater grabbing a disoriented Harry by his jacket.
"Silencio!" Hermione shouted desperately.
Luckily, Harry recovered quickly enough and was able to shout a "Petrificus Totalus!" at another Death Eater that was approaching him.
Hermione's heart filled with pride for Harry's fast reaction.
"Well done, Ha—"
Hermione stopped.
It was as if her heart stopped beating.
A purple light passed through her chest before dissipating into thin air.
The air left her lungs, but as she started losing her balance, she let out a single, weak sound.
"Oh!" Hermione gasped, surprise flowling in her voice.
She did not expect this at all.
The girl started to fall forward, the world around her growing darker with each spin of her vision.
Was this how her end looked like?
Was this going to be the way she died?
Who would tell her parents she died in a magical fight?
Hermione didn't feel the stone floor as she hit it, but she did hear one last cry before closing her eyes, her cheek resting against the ground, yet her mind did not recognize whose voice it was.
"Hermione!"
—
@theunchosenonee
12 notes
·
View notes